97 pts
winepress.com.au - April 2012
Brut Grande Dame 2004. "[...] And the wine delivers. My goodness, does it deliver! Close acquaintances of La Grande Dame will fondly recall the layered complexity of 1998. Six years younger, 2004 is breathtakingly pristine and youthful. Its defining feature is its minerality, its deep and all-pervading chalk. An exceedingly refined fruit profile is alive with energy and awe-inspiring persistence, uniting red fruits, lemon and grapefruit zest with a flicker of mixed spice and toast. [...]"
98 pts
Gilbert & Gaillard - April 2012
Brut Grande Dame 2004. "Pale gold colour. Fine nose with fresh fruit and stone fruit notes, with discreet hints of brioche. It shows seductive fullness on the palate, and its distinctive taste is structured by an ethereal freshness, while its persistance increases in complexity as the seconds go by."
98 pts
Sydney Morning Herald - May 2012
Brut Grande Dame 2004. "A magical wine, refined and stylish, with piercing aromas of citrus and smoky/toasty pinot, a hint of mushroom and even Vegemite. Riche, full palate with profound, powerful flavour. Endless aftertaste of great harmony. Now to six years."
94 pts
Wine enthusiast - September 2012
Brut Grande Dame 2004. "This is a rich and creamy Champagne with a lively mousse, giving it a forward fruit character. Slowly the depth and concentration of the wine come through, with a white fruit flavor and hints of grapefruit and toasty yeast, which all promising good aging."
94 pts
Wine spectator - October 2012
Brut Grande Dame 2004. "Very elegant, this is all in the details: precise and silky texture, mouthwatering acidity and a smoky, mineral undertow that enriches flavors of patisserie pear, crystallized honey, kumquat and toasted almond. Offers a clean, citrus-tinged finish. Drink now through 2027."
19/20
Bettane & Desseauve - November 2012
Brut Grande Dame 2004. "Its style is more consensual than the Vintage, but it has incredible class, this vintage will be a true great: wonderful ethereal volume, marvellous elegance, unforgettable length. Great art."
93 pts
Wine enthusiast - September 2012
Rosé Grande Dame 2004. "This has a toasty edge that complements the ripe red fruit and attractive lemon and yeast character. It seems to be well on its way to maturity, retaining a fruity style while its flavors are beginning to dig deeper."
96 pts
Grandi Champagne 2012 - October 2012
Rosé Grande Dame 2004. "A golden pink colour. A characteristic nose for a rosé which is up there with the very best, those whose embrace is far from syrupy, though it seduces with a profusion of fruity flavours (stone fruit, including medlar, peach, cherry). On the other hand, this wine is so dense that it almost seems closed in on itself, and takes time to reveal its mineral base. This explains the impression on tasting: initially the wine seems inexpressive, but from the first mouthful it opens like an estuary, first full-bodied, then very fruity, and finally mineral, all with a thread of acidity. The finish reveals an almost infinite note of mountain salt, despite a persistant fruity roundness which clings to the palate with a certain stubbornness."